Hobart teacher's sexual abuse appeal dismissed despite judge's social media posts
Stephen Fane Noga's appeal against a $1.6 million damages award was dismissed despite social media bias concerns.
Why it matters
The ruling shows that even apparent judicial bias may be unassailable if procedural objections are not raised in time, raising questions about fairness when timing matters more than substance.
In Australia. Australian courts' handling of social media conduct by judges and procedural rules around challenging bias affect how Australians understand judicial impartiality.
Key facts
- $1.6 million
- Damages awarded
- 13 reposts from Feb 1 to March 21
- Judge's posts
- Stephen Fane Noga, 76
- Defendant age
- 1980s
- Abuse period
- A Hobart teacher sued by a former student for repeated sexual abuse in the 1980s has lost his appeal against a $1.6 million damages award.
- Justice Stephen Estcourt found in favour of the woman.
- Noga's legal team appealed on four grounds, including that Estcourt's social media posts supported victims of sexual abuse and showed bias.
- The Full Court agreed the posts raised reasonable concern of bias.
- However, it ruled Noga waived his right to challenge them by failing to object during the trial.
- The court found he and his team were aware of facts that would justify an objection before trial ended.
- Had the matter been raised then, the judge could have explained the posts or shared other similar ones.
- The case returns to court Thursday for a hearing on legal costs.


