CCTV caught just 3% of incidents in early learning centres
Federal trial found CCTV detected only 3% of 3,386 incidents; active supervision caught 80%.
A government-funded study of 309 early learning services found cameras are not a reliable safety tool. Across 3,386 incidents over three months, staff caught 80%, children speaking up revealed 16%, and CCTV captured just 3%.
When cameras did catch incidents, they were minor: wet floors, tumbles, low-level hazards. Cameras missed abuse because it happens in private spaces like bathrooms and nappy-change areas where filming is banned.
The trial found CCTV useful only for investigations after abuse happens. It does not stop abusers or prevent attacks in real time.
The federal government announced A$11.5 million in grants to help services install or upgrade cameras. Experts warn this spending creates false safety instead of fixing real gaps: proper staff numbers, training, and oversight.
- 3% of 3,386 incidents
- CCTV detection rate
- 80% of incidents caught
- Staff supervision rate
- 309 early learning services
- Trial scope
- A$11.5 million
- Government grants
Why it mattersMoney spent on cameras is money not spent on staff training, staffing levels, and inspections that evidence shows actually prevent harm.
AustraliaAustralian early learning services and the families who use them may be investing in false security instead of the staffing and oversight changes that genuinely protect children.
