Tuesday 17 November, Science & Systems

Person playing violin beside shelves of potted plants under pink LED grow lights

Does music help plants grow? Scientists say the evidence is weak

Dorothy Retallack's famous 1973 study claiming classical music boosts plant growth was never peer-reviewed and was heavily criticised.

Reported by The Conversation

Why it matters

If you thought music helped your plants grow, you can save the speaker and the Spotify subscription.

In Australia. Australian gardeners and houseplant lovers can stop curating playlists for their greenery; the time is better spent on water and sunlight.

Key facts

1973
Study year
Dorothy Retallack
Author
Music student
Background
  • For nearly 70 years, plant lovers have wondered if music helps their gardens.
  • The most famous study came in 1973, when music student Dorothy Retallack reported that rock music killed her plants while classical music made them thrive.
  • The story stuck, but Retallack had little training in the scientific method, her work was never peer-reviewed, and scientists strongly criticised her findings.
  • Modern studies have largely continued in the same vein, but many are also flawed: some report differences that don't exist in their data, others skip statistical analysis, and several are shaped by the researchers' own biases.
  • The real issue?
  • Plants have not evolved to appreciate different music genres, so any study testing whether they do is built on a false premise.
  • Scientists agree there's no evidence plants can distinguish between rock and classical.
Petrol todayFill up or wait? Today's call for every capital

Today on InSnip

  1. Man dies in shooting at Belmont Local Court south of NewcastlePower & Policy, 7NEWS, 2 h ago
  2. David Jones suppliers face months of limbo on $419m debtMoney & Work, The Sydney Morning Herald, 2 h ago
  3. One Nation vows Victoria ban on puberty blockers after states reject guidancePower & Policy, SBS News, 5 h ago

Today's ten are ready.

Read today's tenAbout seven minutes, free