Tuesday 17 November, Sport & Play

File image: Aerial view of packed AFL stadium lit up at night

Pick six looked better on paper: Adelaide's McAsey managed 10 games while

McAsey was Adelaide's pick six in 2019, but played just 10 games while Pickett, pick 12, became one of the game's best.

Reported by The Sydney Morning HeraldClaims checked against the source, 13 h ago.

Why it matters

Draft success determines a club's strength for a decade. These misses cost Adelaide years of competitiveness during a rebuild.

In Australia. Every AFL team has similar regrets. Understanding why highly rated picks fail helps clubs improve their recruitment as the game evolves.

Key facts

10 games
Games played
2019
Draft year
Pick 6
McAsey's pick
Pick 12
Pickett's pick
  • Adelaide drafted Fischer McAsey as a highly rated backman in 2019, hoping he would become a key intercept defender during their rebuild.
  • Fischer McAsey managed just 10 games across five years before quitting after the 2023 season.
  • McAsey later said he lost the "spark" and didn't feel good heading to training in his final two years.
  • In the same draft, Caleb Serong (pick eight) became one of Fremantle's prime movers.
  • Kysaiah Pickett (pick 12) is now one of the best players in the league.
  • Cody Weightman (pick 15) has had injury troubles but remains one of the best small forwards.
  • AFL clubs' draft records since 2011 are littered with similar misses.
  • Adelaide is far from alone in picking promising teenagers who never reached their potential while later picks flourished into stars.
Petrol todayFill up or wait? Today's call for every capital

Today on InSnip

  1. Man dies in shooting at Belmont Local Court south of NewcastlePower & Policy, 7NEWS, 2 h ago
  2. David Jones suppliers face months of limbo on $419m debtMoney & Work, The Sydney Morning Herald, 2 h ago
  3. One Nation vows Victoria ban on puberty blockers after states reject guidancePower & Policy, SBS News, 5 h ago

Today's ten are ready.

Read today's tenAbout seven minutes, free